Forty Thieves vs Spider solitaire
Forty Thieves and Spider are both two-deck patience games played with ten piles, so people often mix them up. They play very differently, though. This page compares the standard rules of each, as described on Wikipedia. For the full Forty Thieves rules, see how to play, or go straight to a random deal.
What they have in common
- Two standard decks, 104 cards.
- Ten piles in the tableau.
- The goal is to sort all 104 cards into eight complete suits from ace to king.
- Piles are built downwards.
The deal
Forty Thieves deals 40 cards in ten piles of four, all face up. You can see every card on the table from the start. The other 64 cards form the stock.
Spider deals 54 cards into ten piles: six cards in each of the first four piles and five in each of the other six. Only the top card of each pile is face up; the rest are face down and get turned over as they are uncovered. The other 50 cards form the stock.
Building on the piles
Forty Thieves builds down in suit only. A 7 of spades can go only on an 8 of spades.
Spider builds down by rank regardless of suit. A 7 of any suit can go on any 8. Building in suit is still worth more, because only same-suit runs can be moved as a group.
Moving cards
Forty Thieves moves one card at a time, always the top card of a pile or of the waste.
Spider lets you move a run of cards together, as long as the run is all one suit and in order.
Empty piles
In both games any card can fill an empty pile. In Spider, a run that could legally be moved can also fill it.
The stock
Forty Thieves turns the stock one card at a time onto a single waste pile. The top waste card is playable. You go through the stock once, with no redeal.
Spider has no waste pile. Each time you use the stock, it deals one card face up onto every one of the ten piles. In the standard game you may only deal from the stock when none of the piles is empty. The 50 stock cards give five such deals.
Foundations
Forty Thieves builds eight foundations up one card at a time, starting from each ace. You can move a card to a foundation as soon as it fits.
Spider has no foundations to build on card by card. Instead, when a complete run of one suit from king down to ace forms on a pile, that whole run is removed. The game is won when all eight runs are removed.
Side by side
| Forty Thieves | Spider | |
|---|---|---|
| Cards dealt | 40 in 10 piles of 4 | 54 in 10 piles (6, 6, 6, 6, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5) |
| Face down at start | None | All but the top card of each pile |
| Build on piles | Down in suit | Down, any suit |
| Move runs | No, one card at a time | Yes, if all one suit |
| Stock | 64 cards, one at a time to a waste pile | 50 cards, one to each pile per deal |
| Waste pile | Yes | No |
| Foundations | Built up from aces, card by card | Complete K to A runs removed |
| Redeal | None | None |
How it feels to play
In Forty Thieves you have full information about the table from the first move, but very tight rules about where each card can go. Most of the difficulty is planning: getting a pile empty, and choosing which stock cards to keep. In Spider, face-down cards hide part of the table, but the looser building rule and the ability to move runs give you more freedom on each move.
If you know Spider and want to try Forty Thieves, the biggest adjustment is the one-card rule. Plan every run as a series of single moves. A good first deal to try is deal #5, or deal #250. The tips for beginners are a good next step.